Ethnic data ‘not always reliable’
24 Mar 2014
New research from The University of Manchester shows official forms cannot record our ethnic group precisely, because many of us change how we identify ourselves each time we are asked.
According to the ESRC Research Centre on Dynamics of Ethnicity, 4% of all people chose a different ethnic group in the 2011 Census than they had in the 2001 Census.
Professor Ludi Simpson said “Ethnicity is a fuzzy concept used by government and sociologists to explain and support the diversity of our society. But as individuals we don’t fit into neat boxes.
“The census form itself changes and encourages people to swap ethnic identities. 26% of White Irish changed their ethnic group from 2001, partly because the census form in 2011 added a note that mentioned that White British could include Northern Irish.”
The research was jointly funded by the University of Manchester and the Joseph Rowntree Foundation. It is published in a Census Briefing and a working paper, which note that the level of instability in the past decade 2001-2011 is twice what was observed for the decade 1991-2001.
Professor Simpson added: “Britain’s growing diversity includes more people whose family background does not fit neatly into one category. This is partly because of immigration from new parts of the world. It is also because we have grown used to defining ourselves by this thing called ethnicity, and more of us are no longer satisfied with the options provided on the census form. We more often write in our own sense of identity.”
The new research recommends the ethnic group categories that can be most reliably compared across the 1991, 2001 and 2011 censuses.
Notes for editors
Professor Simpson is available for comment.
Image courtesy nongpimmy and http://www.freedigitalphotos.net/
The Briefing How have people’s ethnic identities changed in England and Wales? is available on request and from 24 March at http://www.ethnicity.ac.uk/census/ .
The Centre on Dynamics of Ethnicity is funded by the Economic and Social Research Council.
For media enquiries contact:
Faculty of Humanities
The University of Manchester
0161 275 0790