In April 2016 Manchester eScholar was replaced by the University of Manchester’s new Research Information Management System, Pure. In the autumn the University’s research outputs will be available to search and browse via a new Research Portal. Until then the University’s full publication record can be accessed via a temporary portal and the old eScholar content is available to search and browse via this archive.

Seismic Design and Performance of Hospital Structures Equipped with Buckling-Restrained Braces in the Lakebed Zone of Mexico City

Guerrero Bobadilla, Hector

[Thesis]. Manchester, UK: The University of Manchester; 2016.

Access to files

Abstract

Hospitals are regarded as some of the most important structures in society due to the service that they provide. Knowing this, governments spend large amounts of money on these facilities. Also, codes of design require to provide them more reserve capacity than that for conventional structures. However, large damages (such as collapses and permanent or temporary interruptions of their functionality) have still been observed in hospitals during strong earthquakes. Unfortunately, it is precisely after this type of event that their service is in high demand and failure in providing that service could lead to further disastrous or fatal consequences. Therefore, the use of protective technologies, combined with rational procedures of design, would help to reduce damage and probable losses of functionality in hospital structures.In this thesis, a procedure for seismic design of structures equipped with a type of protective technology, namely, buckling-restrained braces (BRBs), is proposed. Then, the results of experimental and numerical studies are presented to understand the benefits of using BRBs in structures. This study highlights that BRBs are very effective to dissipate seismic energy and can act as structural fuses, i.e. disposable devices that may be replaced after an earthquake without interruptions in the functionality of the structure.One of the advantages of the proposed procedure is that it takes into account explicitly the characteristics and contributions of both, the main structure and the BRBs. It is based on the assumption that a structure protected with BRBs can rationally be represented by a dual SDOF system whose parts yield at different displacement levels. Other advantages include: 1) better control of the displacement demands on the structure; 2) achievement of the fuse concept beforehand; and 3) rapid assessment of the probabilistic performance of the structure.The experimental studies consisted of testing steel and concrete models, with and without BRBs, on a shaking table. In addition to calibrate and validate the proposed method of design, the tests have helped to find that, due to BRBs: 1) the damping ratio is increased significantly; and 2) the dynamic response, to ground motions characteristic of the lakebed zone of Mexico City, is reduced in terms of lateral displacements, inter-storey drifts, floor velocities and floor accelerations.The numerical studies are: 1) a study of the response of typical hospitals improved with BRBs; 2) a study of residual displacements in conventional and dual systems; and 3) evaluation of the economic benefits of using BRBs in structures. On these studies, hypothetical hospitals located in the lakebed zone of Mexico City were considered. The results show that the use of BRBs is very beneficial in medium- and low-rise buildings, while adverse effects may be observed in high-rise structures.This thesis, with title: “Seismic Design and Performance of Hospital Structures Equipped with Buckling-Restrained Braces in the Lakebed Zone of Mexico City”, is submitted to The University of Manchester by Hector Guerrero-Bobadilla for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy in February 2016.

Layman's Abstract

Given the importance of hospitals to our modern societies and after the disastrous effects observed in recent earthquakes, this thesis studies the effects of earthquakes in hospitals protected with a type of energy dissipator - which is called Buckling-Restrained Brace (or BRB). The thesis is focused in hospitals located on the very soft soils of Mexico City, where significant amplification of the earthquake movements have been well documented. First, a method for designing structures equipped with BRBs is proposed. The method presents several advantages over current methods of design. These advantages are discussed and a design example is provided to show the applicability of the method. Then, the results of some experiments of building models, appropriate of typical hospitals, with and without BRBs are presented. These results show the improvements of the deformation behaviour due to the introduction of BRBs. Additional to the experiments, numerical studies were also conducted and are presented in this thesis to further understand the effects of BRBs in hospital structures. It has been found that BRBs not only improve their deformation behaviour but also allow significant reductions of economic losses due to future earthquakes. Also, one of the analyses shows that, while BRBs are very effective in medium- and low-rise structures (typical of hospitals), adverse effects could be observed in tall buildings.

Bibliographic metadata

Type of resource:
Content type:
Form of thesis:
Type of submission:
Degree type:
Doctor of Philosophy
Degree programme:
PhD Civil Engineering (CONACyT)
Publication date:
Location:
Manchester, UK
Total pages:
272
Abstract:
Hospitals are regarded as some of the most important structures in society due to the service that they provide. Knowing this, governments spend large amounts of money on these facilities. Also, codes of design require to provide them more reserve capacity than that for conventional structures. However, large damages (such as collapses and permanent or temporary interruptions of their functionality) have still been observed in hospitals during strong earthquakes. Unfortunately, it is precisely after this type of event that their service is in high demand and failure in providing that service could lead to further disastrous or fatal consequences. Therefore, the use of protective technologies, combined with rational procedures of design, would help to reduce damage and probable losses of functionality in hospital structures.In this thesis, a procedure for seismic design of structures equipped with a type of protective technology, namely, buckling-restrained braces (BRBs), is proposed. Then, the results of experimental and numerical studies are presented to understand the benefits of using BRBs in structures. This study highlights that BRBs are very effective to dissipate seismic energy and can act as structural fuses, i.e. disposable devices that may be replaced after an earthquake without interruptions in the functionality of the structure.One of the advantages of the proposed procedure is that it takes into account explicitly the characteristics and contributions of both, the main structure and the BRBs. It is based on the assumption that a structure protected with BRBs can rationally be represented by a dual SDOF system whose parts yield at different displacement levels. Other advantages include: 1) better control of the displacement demands on the structure; 2) achievement of the fuse concept beforehand; and 3) rapid assessment of the probabilistic performance of the structure.The experimental studies consisted of testing steel and concrete models, with and without BRBs, on a shaking table. In addition to calibrate and validate the proposed method of design, the tests have helped to find that, due to BRBs: 1) the damping ratio is increased significantly; and 2) the dynamic response, to ground motions characteristic of the lakebed zone of Mexico City, is reduced in terms of lateral displacements, inter-storey drifts, floor velocities and floor accelerations.The numerical studies are: 1) a study of the response of typical hospitals improved with BRBs; 2) a study of residual displacements in conventional and dual systems; and 3) evaluation of the economic benefits of using BRBs in structures. On these studies, hypothetical hospitals located in the lakebed zone of Mexico City were considered. The results show that the use of BRBs is very beneficial in medium- and low-rise buildings, while adverse effects may be observed in high-rise structures.This thesis, with title: “Seismic Design and Performance of Hospital Structures Equipped with Buckling-Restrained Braces in the Lakebed Zone of Mexico City”, is submitted to The University of Manchester by Hector Guerrero-Bobadilla for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy in February 2016.
Layman's abstract:
Given the importance of hospitals to our modern societies and after the disastrous effects observed in recent earthquakes, this thesis studies the effects of earthquakes in hospitals protected with a type of energy dissipator - which is called Buckling-Restrained Brace (or BRB). The thesis is focused in hospitals located on the very soft soils of Mexico City, where significant amplification of the earthquake movements have been well documented. First, a method for designing structures equipped with BRBs is proposed. The method presents several advantages over current methods of design. These advantages are discussed and a design example is provided to show the applicability of the method. Then, the results of some experiments of building models, appropriate of typical hospitals, with and without BRBs are presented. These results show the improvements of the deformation behaviour due to the introduction of BRBs. Additional to the experiments, numerical studies were also conducted and are presented in this thesis to further understand the effects of BRBs in hospital structures. It has been found that BRBs not only improve their deformation behaviour but also allow significant reductions of economic losses due to future earthquakes. Also, one of the analyses shows that, while BRBs are very effective in medium- and low-rise structures (typical of hospitals), adverse effects could be observed in tall buildings.
Thesis main supervisor(s):
Language:
en

Record metadata

Manchester eScholar ID:
uk-ac-man-scw:300330
Created by:
Guerrero Bobadilla, Hector
Created:
20th April, 2016, 13:08:19
Last modified by:
Guerrero Bobadilla, Hector
Last modified:
5th May, 2017, 12:10:59

Can we help?

The library chat service will be available from 11am-3pm Monday to Friday (excluding Bank Holidays). You can also email your enquiry to us.